The English Patient & the way we were....
The English Patient
=============
"In memory, love lives on forever". How true.
They both fell in love in the dessert, he a wanderer who had no allegiance to anyone or anything. She, a married woman, married to the right guy who could gave her everything that a husband could give except passion. To me, Ralph Fiennes and Kirstin Scott Thomas played the characters really well, displaying bottled passion, anguished torment, sanely restraint and the final doomed acceptance beautifully. I find it beautiful that they did not utter love or undying promises or ask anything of the other. They both knew, they both understood, and they both accepted the final deathly price. Both of them died very tragically, but not before he walked in the dessert and betrayed everyone so that he could save the life of the woman he loved. I cried when Almasy said aloud "my wife is dying", validating Katherine's place in his life. At that point, it was clear that it was not just a woman dying in the dessert. His wife was dying, and along with her, his life too. To me, that was a very beautifully scripted moment that a man was willing to sell everything to fight for a chance to keep someone alive.
I loved every slow moment of this rich movie. The beauty of the dessert and post-war wreckage, the richness of human exploration, the suffering, the war-torn human lives and the much lingering human emotions that lingered after everything has been lost. Perhaps if he had a different name, she would have survived as suggested in the movie. But we dont really know
from the Booker Prize-winning book.
I have heard a lot of criticisms about this movie. It is definitely not a movie for the pro-family, religious and righteous people. It was just lust, perhaps but I thought the most valid objection was that it was a very selfish love. That both Almasy and Katherine loved dangerously without thinking about the consequences for others around them. Yes, they did that and for that, they had a tragic ending. To me, it is better to have love and lost, than to have never loved at all. In the end, Almasy had nothing, no face, no name and only memory......
The Way We Were
=============
This is another love story that had me crying copiously. I hated Robert Redford character in the show and I could not find myself sympathizing with Barbara Streisand's character either. They both did not die in the movie but they both separated eventually despite loving the other person very much. I think this movie only works in the hippy seventies where personal expression and beliefs triumphed over love haha... Robert Redford was so good looking then. As much as one could be outraged at him being with another passionless woman in the end, one could understand his decision. As much as he was attracted by her zest, passion and zeal in life, he wanted a different life. She fought and won for what she believe in, but lost the man she wanted. So they are not compatible together. As simple as that. And the song sung by Barbara really tugged at my heart, perhaps because I could emphatise with their decisions. Some times, in life, what one wants may not be what one could live with. And that is just as simple as it was, the way things were..
